How to Troubleshoot Problems in your Volunteer Role

By: Volunteer Success

Just like in a paid role, sometimes the experience "on the job" isn’t what you expected. Pay attention to these red flags when volunteering:

  • You aren’t using the skills that you had hoped to use: for example, stuffing envelopes instead of helping clients at reception
  • Staff are too busy to properly train or supervise you
  • The staff ignore you and you feel like an outsider and not part of a team
  • The organization doesn’t know what to do with you and you end up waiting around to be told what to do
  • You don’t feel like you are contributing to anything
  • You aren’t sure who your supervisor is because you have different people telling you what to do
  • Your supervisor isn’t friendly or supportive
  • No one thanks you for your time and contributions and you feel unappreciated
  • You are either feeling confused or bored, or both!

If these things start happening to you, don’t just ghost the organization and stop showing up! Try to problem-solve the situation with the supervisor or the Volunteer Services Manager who initially placed you. Letting them know that there is a problem is great feedback for them and they should take your concerns seriously.

Managing volunteers well takes a great deal of planning and thought and if the organization doesn’t have things organized behind the scenes, then it helps them when you let them know what the problems are. Many non-profit organizations are volunteer-run themselves (there are no staff, only volunteers) and likely those volunteers are only working on a part-time basis. Or the coordinator may be a staff person juggling multiple roles, for instance fundraising and volunteer coordination. Under those circumstances, there may be a good chance that there isn’t enough time to properly organize a large number of volunteers.

Here’s what you can do:

  • Set up a time to meet with the supervisor or the Volunteer Services Manager to discuss the problems and have a clear description of what is happening.
  • Stick to the facts and describe the situation non-judgmentally. Use I statements: “When this (fill in the blank) happened, I felt this way or I reacted this way.
  • If the issue is with your supervisor, talk to the person who interviewed and placed you
  • Have your position description on hand. If you didn’t get one, that could be the problem right there. Perhaps they don’t have a good plan in place as to what volunteers should be doing.
  • Make sure you understand how your role contributes to the larger mission of the organization. Even small mundane tasks can help: for instance, being a greeter at reception or event makes you the “face of the organization” and helps clients and visitors feel welcomed.
  • If you are feeling isolated, ask if you can do your work with another volunteer so that you can do the work as part of a team of two or more.
  • Ask if you can be placed elsewhere in the organization. Perhaps there is another department with a more supportive and more organized supervisor.

If after trying to problem-solve your issues, nothing gets resolved or changed, then it may be time to move on. Volunteering needs to be win-win: good for you and for the organization.

  • If you decide to resign, email the staff supervisor or Volunteer Services Manager and let them know well before your next shift that you will not be returning.
  • Let them know your reasons for leaving and that if things change in the future, that you may be willing to come back (but only if that’s the case).
  • Ask for your verification of completed volunteer hours if you need it for school
  • Be polite and professional in your tone
  • Fill in the Exit Survey if they send you one and give them your feedback - professionally!
  • Don’t get discouraged! Learn from this experience to find something that you really enjoy! Ask questions in your next interview so that you know that the organization has all their “ducks in a row” in order to manage volunteers properly. Are they clear about:
    • What they want you to do (they can give you a position description) and why the role is important?
    • Who is supervising you and who you are working with?
    • What kind of orientation and training is offered?
    • How will they make you feel part of the team?
    • Do they have volunteer testimonials on their website?

Need to start over? Review: How to Find the Right Opportunity

Found a fix to your problem? Review: How-to Tips for Working in your Volunteer Role

Also check out: How to Get a Reference and/or a Paid Job!

Also read…

The Happiness Advantage

By: Tony Goodrow

Assuming that we could all use a little boost of happiness these days, I want to share some thoughts from a great book with you. If you get something out of it, I highly suggest getting your hands on the book for the full read. Below is a mix of Achor’s words directly from his book, The Happiness Advantage, my own summary of some of his points and my own reflections, including some thoughts on how this might be applicable to volunteer or donor management. Many of us have been taught that if we become successful, we will then become happy. The success, we’ve been told, has to come first. But Shawn Achor calls that whole notion into question. Recent research in the fields of positive psychology and neuroscience have proven that we’ve had the order in the relationship between success and happiness all wrong. It is not that success leads to happiness, but rather, that happiness leads to success. Doctors in a positive mood demonstrated almost 3 times more intelligence and creativity in diagnosing a case than doctors in a neutral state, and they made accurate diagnoses 19 times faster (and all it took to make them think happy thoughts was to be given a lollipop!) Optimistic salespeople outsell pessimist salespeople by over 50% Students made to feel happy about something before a math test outperform their neutral peers This has three important ramifications in volunteer management and donor relations. If you start your day or ready yourself for a challenging task by reflecting on things that make you happy or doing something that makes you happy, you’ll perform better for it. The environment in which your volunteers are engaged clearly matters. If they are happy, what they will succeed in accomplishing for you will go up. Campaigns encouraging donors to give out of a sense of happiness create a different experience with your organization than campaigns encouraging donors to give out of a sense of guilt. Happiness can act as an inoculation against stress. Tax season, as you can imagine, is a very stressful time for tax auditors. To put his seven principles to the test, Achor delivered three hours of positive psychology training to 250 managers at KPMG. When tested again later on, those auditors that had gone through the training reported significantly higher life satisfaction scores and lower stress levels than the control group who had not received the training. Change is possible. You might think that you are who are and that’s that. A growing body of science is teaching us that this just isn’t the case. Advances in the field of neuroplasticity show that the human brain has enormous growth potential. We don’t know the limits, but we do know that science has proven that brains can and do change and grow, that there are numerous ways we can rewire our brains, and that adopting the habits that improve our mindset have proven, long-lasting effects.

Creating Inclusive Nonprofit Boards: Making Room at Your Table for Difference

By: K. Bron Johnson

Can you imagine an organization said to support Black people with no or just one Black person on the board? It’s like a panel discussing women’s rights with no women (which also happens). It makes no sense. “If they don’t give you a seat at the table, bring a folding chair,” is a famous quote by Shirley Chisholm I often hear in advocacy groups. I still believe it’s sound advice, but it also doesn’t capture how hard it can be for some people to carry around their chair everywhere, all the time. And it takes the pressure off the others at the table — they don’t have to change a thing. They are comfortably sitting in their chairs and don’t even have to acknowledge your chair is different or how much effort it took for you to bring it to the table. “If they don’t give you a seat at the table, bring a folding chair”

HOW TO RECRUIT AND ENGAGE INTROVERTED VOLUNTEERS

By: Lesley Taylor

In 2002, when Marty Olsen Laney wrote The Introvert Advantage, it was believed that only one-third of the general population had introverted tendencies. But in a 2010 article in Psychology Today, Nancy Helgoe noted that introverts make up 50% of the U.S. population. Why the discrepancy? According to Helgoe, “Our perceptual biases lead us to overestimate the number of extroverts because they are noisier and tend to hog the spotlight.” In reality, many introverts describe themselves as social, creative and, yes, dynamic. Checking your assumptions and learning as much as you can about introverts are positive first steps toward engaging them in your organization.